Understanding different management styles is key to running a smooth, collaborative, and encouraging environment in your small business.
Whether you’re already a manager or looking to make the shift, we’ve listed all the management styles, along with their pros and cons. Read on.
What is a management style in the workplace?
A management style in the workplace is the way a manager leads, supports, communicates with and makes decisions about their team to achieve business goals.
Why is leadership style in management important?
Management styles influence how managers delegate tasks, motivate employees, handles challenges, provides feedback and involves team members in decision-making processes.
What are the types of management style?
There are a few different types of management style you should be aware of as a small business owner or manager. We’ve listed them below.
Autocratic
The manager makes decisions alone and expects them to be followed. It’s efficient in a crisis or with inexperienced teams, but it can hurt morale and creativity over time.
Democratic (participative)
This is where the manager asks for team input before deciding, building engagement and often producing strong ideas.
Laissez-faire (delegative)
The manager sets goals and largely leaves the team to get on with it. It works well with skilled, self-motivated people.
Transformational
The focus is on inspiring people around a vision and encouraging growth and change. It’s common in fast-moving or innovative organisations.
Transactional
Performance is managed through clear structures, targets, rewards, and consequences. It suits routine, results-driven work like sales or operations.
Servant leadership
The manager puts the team’s needs first, removing obstacles and supporting development so people can do their best work.
Coaching
This is developing individuals’ skills over the long term rather than just hitting short-term targets.
Paternalistic
The manager makes decisions in what they see as employees’ best interests, often with a strong focus on wellbeing and loyalty.
Why does management style matter?
A management style in the workplace matters because it shapes how people experience their work every day. It affects how decisions get made, how clearly expectations are set, how problems are handled, and whether people feel trusted and heard. Being aware of your style makes you a better manager because you can see when it works and when it doesn’t, and adjust accordingly.
What are the pros and cons of each management style?
Of course, each management style has its strengths and drawbacks. We’ve listed them below.
| Style | Pros | Cons |
| Autocratic The manager makes decisions alone and expects them to be followed. | Fast decision-making Clear direction and accountability Effective in crises or with inexperienced staff | Can lower morale and motivation Stifles creativity and new ideas Creates over-reliance on the manager |
| Democratic (participative) The manager asks for team input before making decisions | Higher engagement and buy-in Draws on the team’s ideas and expertise Builds trust and job satisfaction | Slower decisions Can stall when people disagree Unsuitable when quick action is needed |
| Laissez-faire (delegative) The manager sets goals and largely leaves the team to get on with the work. | Gives skilled people freedom and ownership Encourages creativity and initiative Frees up the manager’s time | Can lead to confusion or lack of direction Some people underperform without structure Accountability can become blurred |
| Transformational The manager inspires people around a vision and encourages growth and change. | Inspires and motivates people Drives innovation and change Encourages personal growth | Can neglect day-to-day detail Risk of burnout from constant change Depends heavily on the leader’s charisma |
| Transactional Performance is managed through clear structures, targets, rewards and consequences. | Clear expectations and targets Easy to measure performance Works well for routine, results-driven tasks | Limits creativity and initiative Motivation can be purely about rewards People may do the minimum required |
| Servant leadership The manager puts the team’s needs first, removing obstacles and supporting development. | Strong loyalty and trust Supports wellbeing and development Fosters a collaborative culture | Decisions can be slow Manager may be seen as lacking authority Manager may neglect their own workload |
| Coaching The manager focuses on developing individuals’ skills over the long term. | Develops skills and future leaders Improves long-term performance Employees feel invested in | Time-consuming Less effective when quick results are needed Only works if employees are open to development |
| Paternalistic The manager makes decisions in what they see as employees’ best interests, with a focus on wellbeing and loyalty. | Strong loyalty and low turnover Employees feel cared for Stable, family-like culture | Can feel controlling or condescending Limits employee independence Can create dependence on the manager |
| Situational The manager adapts their style to the situation and the person involved. | Adapts to each person and situation Uses the strengths of every style Suits teams with mixed experience | Can seem inconsistent to staff Requires strong judgement and experience Harder to apply well than a single style |
[H2] Can you only have one management style?
No, you do not have to use only one management style in the workplace. Effective managers adapt their management style to suit the situation, the needs of their employees and business tasks or objectives.
This could look like:
1. Managing a new employee
A manager may adopt an autocratic or directive management style when an employee is new to the role and needs clear instructions, guidance and close supervision. As the employee gains experience and confidence, the manager can shift towards a more delegative style, giving them greater independence and responsibility.
2. Dealing with an urgent deadline
When a team faces a tight deadline or an unexpected problem, a manager could use a more authoritative and decisive style to make quick decisions, allocate tasks and ensure work is completed on time. Once the immediate pressure has passed, they may adopt a more democratic style, encouraging employees to share ideas and contribute to future planning.
Which leadership style in management is best for small businesses?
For small businesses, a democratic or situational management style is often effective, as it allows managers to involve employees in decisions while remaining flexible enough to respond to the changing needs of the business.
However, the best management style depends on the size of the team, the manager’s experience, the nature of the work and the business’s goals.
1. Democratic management style
A democratic manager encourages employees to contribute ideas and participate in decision-making. This style:
- Encourages collaboration and creativity.
- Helps employees feel valued and involved.
- Allows managers to benefit from the team’s knowledge and experience.
2. Situational management style
A situational manager adapts their approach according to the circumstances and the needs of individual employees. This style:
- Provides flexibility when resources and workloads change.
- Allows new employees to receive more guidance while experienced staff work independently.
- Helps managers respond to unexpected challenges quickly.
3. Transformational management style
A transformational manager motivates employees by communicating a clear vision, encouraging new ideas and supporting employees’ professional development. This style:
- Builds a shared sense of purpose.
- Encourages innovation and continuous improvement.
- Can help employees feel motivated to contribute to the business’s growth.
Different management styles can contribute to positive business growth. Want to find out how this looks for your business? Contact one of our expert accountants for a FREE consultation!
Next, read our article on inheritance tax for small businesses here.